Tuesday, November 14, 2006

Freedom of speech and the BNP

Freedom of speech is an issue which has been touched upon in this blog from time to time. For example, we have considered, you and I, Kembrew McLeod's book Freedom of Expression, and we have looked, more than once, at the wonders of the English law of libel. We noted that the most famous English libel lawyer, Peter Carter-Ruck, was described at his death as a man 'who did for freedom of speech what the Boston Strangler did for door-to-door salesmen.'

And so on. But connoisseurs of this issue, particularly those outside the UK, may like to take note of a circumstance which has arisen in England during the last week.

There exists in the UK a small political party known as the British National Party (BNP). The party has a mission statement which you can read for yourself, but I don't think the members would complain too loudly if you described them as a white supremacist group. They might, perhaps, demur a bit if you described them as fascist, though plenty of their critics wouldn't hesitate to use that description. You could also describe them, in shorthand terms, as anti-immigration. Indeed the party leader seems to have made no secret of his view that all immigrants should be shipped back home -- wherever home is.

The party is headed by a Cambridge law graduate called Nick Griffin, and for several years now he has been going around making speeches -- as politicians do. Quite often, it seems, these speeches are made in front of audiences which deliberately do not include members of the press or other media.

Not surprisingly, perhaps, this exclusion policy aroused suspicion as to what was being said, and in 2004 the BBC smuggled in a camera and sound system to make a secret film of Griffin in action. Parts of the speech so recorded were then shown on TV.

In his speech, Griffin can be heard pointing out that, if the police got to know what he was saying to his supporters, he could get seven years in prison. So much, he implied, for the principle of free speech. He also described Islam as a 'wicked, vicious faith', and said that Muslims were turning Britain into a 'multi-racial hell hole'.

Sure enough, when this matter was drawn to the attention of Inspector Knacker of the Yard, and other authorities, Griffin was in due course prosecuted for using words likely to incite racial hatred.

At the first trial the jury failed to agree. But instead of then dropping the case, the authorities forced a retrial. However, on 10 November a jury in Leeds unanimously brought in a not guilty verdict on both Griffin and a colleague who faced similar charges. This verdict was promptly hailed by the BNP as a victory for free speech.

There were numerous reactions to this series of events. The most important, however, came from the man who is thought by some to be our next Prime Minister -- if ever, that is, our beloved Mr Blair should (God forbid) step down. Our next Prime Minister promptly declared that, since Mr Griffin had been acquitted, it was obviously necessary to tighten up the laws about what could and could not be said on racial matters.

But wait. By a curious coincidence (if you believe in coincidences), on precisely the same day as Mr Griffin was cracking open the champagne (kindly donated, the BNP tells us, by a French right-wing party), a speech was being made by Dame Eliza Manningham-Buller, the head of MI5.

Aside for overseas readers. MI5 (once department 5 of the Ministry of Information) is the body responsible for anti-espionage (and nowadays anti-terror) work in the UK. MI6 (the outfit that James Bond worked for) is reponsible for gathering intelligence from overseas. John Le Carre worked for both at various times.

Dame Eliza was speaking, as Mr Griffin had been, to a 'specially invited audience', and not to the general public. However, her remarks were issued to the press and were posted on the MI5 web site.

Young British Muslims, said Dame Eliza, were being groomed to become suicide bombers and her agents were tracking some 1,600 suspects, most of whom were British-born and linked to al Qaeda in Pakistan. 'We are aware of numerous plots to kill people and damage our economy. What do I mean by numerous? Five? Ten? No, nearer 30 ... That we know of.'

Here is another direct quotation from her speech: 'The extremists are motivated by a sense of grievance and injustice driven by their interpretation of the history between the West and the Muslim world. This view is shared, in some degree, by a far wider constituency. If the opinion polls conducted in the UK since July 2005 are only broadly accurate, over 100,000 of our citizens consider that the July 2005 attacks in London were justified.'

The response to this speech from Mr Blair, our glorious leader whom Allah preserve, was: 'I think she is absolutely right in saying that it will last a generation.... This terror threat is very real,' he added.

So. Mr Griffin describes Islam as wicked and vicious, and gets prosecuted for inciting racial hatred. The head of MI5 says that the range of factors that are motivating acts of terrorism include perceived injustices against Muslims around the world and extreme interpretations of Islam, and Mr Blair pats her on the back.

The fact that there is a a bit of a left hand/right hand problem here has not, you will be pleased to hear, gone completely unnoticed. For comment, you could try, for example, Rod Liddle in the Sunday Times, or Libby Purves in today's Times, or just read the letters in today's Times.

And if you're really, really keen, when you've absorbed all that, and are in training to face an audience or become a Church of England vicar or something, then you might like to limber up by preparing answers to a few questions of the sort that used to appear in examination papers set by the great universities of Oxford and Cambridge. (What the present practice is in those universities I know not; but, at a guess, candidates probably don't have to write essays any longer; just tick boxes. Such is progress.)

Anyway, as I say, here are a few questions of the kind that arts graduates of my generation used to have to answer: usually at the rate of four in a three-hour paper.

1. 'The English were driven insane by the second world war.' Discuss in relation to the immigration policies of successive British governments since 1945.

2. Enoch Powell was right. Discuss.

3. Compare and contrast the political philosophies of Mr Blair and Mr Griffin.

4. Immigration is one thing; occupation is another; and occupation by racial groups which are plotting the destruction of their host communities is yet a third. Discuss in relation to the present position in some British cities.

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

All of which does much to suggest Emerson was right in saying that what one does out-shouts what one says. In the colonies we have an abundance of people babbling at all ends of the spectrum (there are more than two, here) on issues from immigration to ethics to the mission in Iraq (accomplished in 2003), yet everyone is frozen in their steps.

Thus, the loonies stand no better a chance of being heard than the more rational (if the latter even exist any more).

Anonymous said...

I am against the death penalty, but do think commentspammers should be force fed the products they promote.

However, whatever happened to that proposed blasphemy law in Britain?

Anonymous said...

This may be of interest:

http://www.englishpen.org/news/pensendsopenletter/

archer said...

I remember Powell very well. As I recall, he liked to tell stories about British children (the white kind, presumably) being chased down the street by hordes of "little pickaninnies." Americans should not scoff, as that was more or less the same year that Alabama Gov. George C.Wallace did very, very well in the U.S. Presidential primaries.

Elberry said...

i've always lived near Pakistani neighbourhoods, and while individual Muslims may be ok, in general they do not 'integrate', and have no wish to. i have substantial experience of the a priori hostility & suspicion that many Muslims feel for non-Muslims.

The only bearable Muslims i've met were the equivalent of 'nominal Xians', i.e. didn't eat pork, kept the Ramadan fast, but otherwise never thought about it. Their religion was purely a dietary matter. i'm sure there are plenty of them out there; trouble is, there are i suspect even more Fundamentalists, who regard non-Muslims as 'the devil', make no effort to learn English, live entirely in Muslim ghettos, and wish in effect to recreate Pakistan in England. The hostility they engender in non-Muslims feeds back into their own siege mentality; this is likely to worsen over time.

Small pockets of insulated, hostile non-Englishness are undesirable but not a problem. But these are not small pockets. Add some semtex and the Jolly Roger's Cookbook to the mix and it doesn't look too good.

i am, by the way, of mongrel blood, and know Pakistanis who regard Muslims as dangerous lunatics, so accusations of racism are not recommended.

ivan said...

Grumpy,
The huns are at the gates and they are catapulting Spam.
All sorts of groups are planning to take over the host nation.
Because of stupid, stifling "hate" laws,we are limited in our freedom of speech.
I did agree with a qote by old Nazi-hunter Elie Wiesel though: Once language goes to hell, everything goes to hell.
I am just so ticked that there are some things we can't write about.
This has happened in British history before.
So we wallow in Gongorism?

Annette said...

I do not know a lot about the libel law, but it does seem to me that like we live in a goldfish bowl! You have to be so careful what you say even when you are talking to your friends. I don't know how people in the public get on.

ivan said...

Yes, pigeon weather.
I visited San Antonio recently and got a fresh take on Sam Houston.

But then what we had done to our Indians here in Canada!

Biological warfare. Training schools. Sexual abuse by priests.

Oh how pretty we all are.

Anonymous said...

Sadly, this just highlights how impossible it has become to have a rational debate on immigration in the UK.

Griffin and his fascist friends are using the immigration debate as a way of hijacking the very real problem of young Muslims being brainwashed by extremists in the UK. Whilst the two issues are important and pressing, they are not the same issue at all. Using immigration as an excuse for all Britain's ills is an old and nasty trick. And it stops any kind of rational and mature debate on how to combat or prevent terror carried out by extremist groups.

It's terribly sad and dangerous that Britain acquits racist idiots.

experttechhelp said...

Dial Xerox Customer Service Phone Number for Xerox Printer, Call at Xerox Printer Toll Free to resolve Xerox Printer set up/Installation issues by technical support Experts. Xerox Printer Customer Service Number (+1855-834-2054).Xerox Printer Customer Service Number

torrentgems said...

great information corporate gifts and branding

parveen seo expert said...

Good Article ...Thanks for shraing
All Blog Hindi
Rubina Dilaik
Bharti Singh
Disha Patani
Giaa Manek

yanmaneee said...

lebron 18
yeezy
hermes handbags
golden goose
yeezy boost 350
curry shoes
nike sb dunks
off white
yeezys
off white nike

sycowd said...

advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai
advertising agency dubai

maxart advertising said...

advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai

VIP Car Rental said...

advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai
advertising company in dubai

maxart advertising said...

digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai
digital marketing in dubai

sycowd said...

web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai

fatoraio said...

web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai

sycowd said...

video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai

vipcarrental said...

video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai
video production in dubai

sycowd said...

social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai

maxart advertising said...

social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai

fatoraio said...


social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai
social media agency dubai

sycowd said...

Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai
Branding Agency Dubai

fatoraio said...

web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai
web development dubai

sycowd said...

branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai
branding agency in dubai

prismleadindia said...

article looks good and wonderful.
prism lead india is best business listing company for CA service, Modular Kitchen Design, Painting, Packers and movers, Event Organizer. we provide good services

Commercial Interior Designer Bangalore
Interior designers in Bangalore
tv repair service near me
refrigerator repairing near me/

sycowd said...

Our goal is to make your dream car a reality. With a range of vehicles that will make you feel like a boss, you'll be driving like a pro.
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out
check it out

smatha said...

i5g97b4p27 q7t91l5r99 z2l12z6i18 l4c14f2l67 f1x76a3v17 a5z40m2w12